On the Legitimacy Basis for the Application of"Acting for Good Reason"Under the Background of Developing Independent Knowledge System of Criminal Law
摘要
作为我国刑法中常见用语的"事出有因",由于缺乏系统性的理论解读,其虽然在司法实践中被高频率地适用,但在具体裁判上常常存在分歧.无论是实现出罪的"事出有因"还是改变定性的"事出有因",抑或影响量刑的"事出有因",均应具有统一适用的正当性基础和判断规则.然而,不管是客观危险有限说、主观恶性下降说,还是被害人过错存在说、期待可能性适用说,在解释我国刑法中的"事出有因"时,总存在说理上的掣肘,无法提供充分的理论依据.以社会相当性理论作为解构我国刑法中"事出有因"确定行为违法性的有无、不法程度高低的基础,具有统一的解释力.社会相当性中的"通常性"的判断,能够确定"事出有因"行为违法性是否下降;"适当性"的判断最终决定"事出有因"行为违法性是否被排除.在构建刑法自主知识体系的时代背景下,以此,可以实现我国本土司法用语和阶层化犯罪论体系之间的有效兼容,为我国刑法中的"事出有因"塑造规范形象.以"事出有因"的释义为契机,也可以推进中国刑法自主知识体系微观图景的刻画.
As a commonly used expression in China's criminal law,"acting for good reason"is frequently applied in judicial practice yet often leads to contradictory judgments due to the absence of systematic theoretical interpretations.Whether this phrase serves to justify exculpation,alter the nature of an act,or influence sentencing,the legitimate basis and determination criteria should be universally applied.However,theories such as the limited objective risk theory,the diminished subjective malignancy theory,the victim fault theory,and the theory of legitimate expectation all face difficulties in reasoning when explaining"acting for good reason"under China's criminal law,and thus fail to provide sufficient theoretical grounds.By contrast,the social adequacy theory can serve as a sound basis for analyzing this phrase to determine the existence and degree of illegality of relevant acts,boasting universal explanatory power.The assessment of the"ordinariness"within the framework of social adequacy can help decide whether the illegality of an act committed for good reason is mitigated,while the assessment of"adequacy"ultimately decide whether such illegality is completely eliminated.Against the backdrop of developing an independent knowledge system of criminal law,this approach can effectively integrate indigenous judicial expressions with the tiered system on criminality and shape the normative connotation of"acting for good reason"in the criminal law of China.Taking the interpretation of this phrase as a springboard,it is able to advance the refinement of the micro-level framework of China's independent knowledge system of criminal law.