"有关法律问题的决定"的产生、样态与效力
The Formation,Forms,and Legal Force of the"Decision on Legal Issues"
摘要
2023年修改后的《立法法》对"有关法律问题的决定"进行规定.可从"是否经由特定的制定程序"和"是否具有法的规范性特征"两个层面,大致确定"有关法律问题的决定"的范围."有关法律问题的决定"之名表明其与法律有着多种形式的关联:一是替代法律的"有关法律问题的决定",其在立法条件不成熟、立法时间紧迫、立法内容不健全时,对本应由法律调整的社会关系加以调整;二是细化法律的"有关法律问题的决定",其将法律中的原则性规定具体化;三是变更法律的"有关法律问题的决定",其常见于渐进式改革领域,用以实现法律特定内容的具体变更;四是执行法律的"有关法律问题的决定",其为全国人大及其常委会履行法定职责提供行权载体.前三类决定有着与法律同等的效力层级,第四类决定的效力应低于被执行的法律.
The revised Legislation Law of 2023 provides for the"decision on legal issues".The scope of such decisions can be roughly determined according to two standards,i.e."whether a specific enactment procedure is undergone"and"whether the normative characteristics of law are possessed".The term of the"decision on legal issues"indicates that it is linked to the law in some way.First,there is a"decision on legal issues"that substitutes for laws and regulates social relations that would otherwise be governed by laws when legislative conditions are not mature,the legislative schedule is tight,or the legislative content is incomplete.Second,there is a"decision on legal issues"that elaborates laws and concretizes principled provisions set out in laws.Third,there is a"decision on legal issues"that modifies laws,and is commonly found in progressive reform field,and used to effectuate specific changes to particular content of the law.Fourth,there is a"decision on legal issues"that implements laws,which serves as a vehicle for the National People's Congress and its Standing Committee to exercise their statutory duties and powers.The first three categories of decisions have the same legal force as laws,while the fourth category of decisions has lower legal force than the laws it implement.
年,卷(期):
2026, (9)
分类号:
DF01
机标分类号:
D922.22
F270
F832
在线出版日期:
2026年10月19日
基金项目:
21CFX013:国家社会科学基金,