Reflections on the Standardization of Sentencing for Petite Offenses Through the Lens of Limiting Retributivism
摘要
作为当代最有影响力的量刑理论,限制报应理论实质上是深化并超越了并合主义的理论,可为我国的量刑规范化改革提供技术原论.以4238份危险驾驶罪判决书和1984份故意伤害罪判决书为样本,设置回归模型并进行实证分析可以发现,微罪与非微罪的量刑起点确定机制并不存在显著差异,因此导致微罪报应刑过度扩张;预防刑情节对责任刑的限制功能在微罪裁量中被严重忽视,与非微罪形成倒挂现象;微罪缓刑裁量机制未能凸显特别预防属性,责任刑与预防刑的混合评价导致微罪缓刑适用率偏低.鉴于此,应以限制报应理论为基础,构建微罪的分层量刑机制,在微罪量刑观念上树立成本效益观与刑罚表达功能观;在技术操作上优化量刑起点确定程式,强化预防刑情节对责任刑的限制作用;建立科学的再犯罪风险评估制度,构建微罪一般缓刑机制.
As one of the most influential contemporary approaches to sentencing,limiting retributivism essentially transcends the theory of combined purposes of punishment while further developing it,and can provide a theoretical foundation for the technical design of China's sentencing standardization reform.To identify deficiencies in the sentencing mechanism for petite offenses in judicial practice,this study conducts an empirical analysis using regression models and a dataset comprising 4,238 judgments of dangerous-driving cases and 1,984 judgments of intentional-injury cases.The findings show that there is no significant difference between petite offenses and more non-petite offenses in the mechanism of determining the sentencing starting point,resulting in an excessive expansion of the retributive punishment for petite offenses;the function of circumstances of preventive punishment in limiting culpability-based punishment is seriously overlooked in petite offenses sentencing,producing a disproportionately harsher punishment compared with non-petite offenses;the sentencing mechanism of suspended sentences for petite offenses likewise fails to highlight the nature of special prevention and the hybrid assessment from perspectives of culpability-based punishment and preventive punishment results in an unduly low rate of suspended sentences in petite-offence cases.Accordingly,it is necessary,on the theoretical basis of limiting retributivism,to develop a tiered sentencing mechanism for petite offenses,and establish the cost-benefit view and the view of expressive function of punishment at the concept level;and at the operational level,to improve the formula of determining the sentencing starting point,and enhance the extent to which circumstances of preventive punishment limit culpability-based punishment;to establish a scientifically grounded system for assessing the reoffending risk,and the mechanism of generally granting suspended sentences for petite offenses.