军事知识服务平台
从"一费一征"到"税费一体化":非税收入征管的法治转型
From"Fee-by-Fee Levy Approach"to"Integration of Taxes and Fees":the Law-based Transformation of Non-Tax Revenue Collection Administration
摘要 我国目前在税费统征的征管体制下,还延续着"一费一征"的规范模式,税务部门权责与缴费人权利都面临规范缺位的困境.各地为实现"税费皆重"的政策诉求,创制出非税收入征管保障的一般性、类型化与参照税收的不同规则类型,但也存在地方难以设权、忽视税费差异、数字化扩张导致缴费人权利风险的问题.因此,非税收入征管应以"税费一体化"为法治出路,即在廓清非税收入划转征管范围之前提下,以债为基础提炼税费征管之共性规则,以受益性为标准类型化检视特性规则之体系设定.有鉴于单独立法、借用税收征收管理法、统合于收入法典三类立法模式与特征,应选择在《中华人民共和国税收征收管理法》中规定引致条款以借用税收的程序债法规则,并遵循分类、分地思路在各类非税单行法、各地税费征收管理立法中继续完善特性规则,进而通过明确税务部门责任与健全缴费人权利救济机制,以保障非税收入征管规范的法治实施.
Abstract:
Currently,under the administration system of unified collection of taxes and fees in China,the normative model of"fee-by-fee levy approach"is still in effect,and both the tax authorities' power and responsibilities and the payers' rights are facing the predicament of the absence of governing norms.To satisfy the policy demands of"equal emphasis on taxes and fees",various regions have created different types of rules for the safeguard of non-tax revenue collection administration,i.e.generality,classification and reference to taxes.However,there are issues such as local authorities' difficulty in creating such power and neglect of the differences between taxes and fees and the expansion of digitalization leading to risks in the payers' rights.Therefore,regarding the non-tax revenue collection administration,it is necessary to take"integration of taxes and fees"as the rule-of-law solution,namely,on the premise of clarifying the scope of the administration of transferred collection of non-tax revenues,to distill the common rules for the taxes and fees collection administration on basis the debt,and carry out a classification-based review of the systematical establishment of special rules based on the criterion of benefit.Given the three legislative models and characteristics of stand-alone legislation,applying mutatis mutandis the law on tax collection administration,integration into the revenue code,it is necessary to choose to stipulate referral clauses in Chinese Law on Tax Collection Administration to apply mutatis mutandis the debt-based procedural rules for taxes,and follow the classification-based and region-divided way of thinking to continue improving the special rules in various non-tax standalone laws and local tax collection administration legislation,thus ensuring the legal implementation of the norms on non-tax revenue collection administration through clarifying the responsibilities of the tax authorities and improving the rights remedy mechanism for the payers.
刊 名 政治与法律 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (9)
分类号: DF432
机标分类号: D9 D693 K26
在线出版日期: 2026年10月19日
基金项目: 2024NDQN027:重庆市社会科学规划项目25FFXB069:国家社会科学基金,