军事知识服务平台
论违法建筑的违法性及其评价
On the Illegality of Illegal Buildings and Its Assessment
摘要 违法建筑治理的前提是其被依法认定,该认定本质上属于对建筑物违法性的法律评价.实践中通常以是否取得规划许可作为认定违法建筑的标准,但规划许可只能识别建设行为的程序违法,不能当然决定建筑物是否具有实体违法性.单纯以许可状态作为判断依据,难以适应违法建筑成因复杂、利益结构多元的社会现实.违法建筑的违法性评价可区分具有递进关系的三个层次:程序性评价以规划许可为中心,确认建设行为是否违反事前建设管控程序;实体性评价以土地利用、国土空间保护、城乡规划及技术标准等实体性制定法规则为依据,判断建筑物是否违反具有约束力的实体规则;实质性评价则在实体规则不足、形式适用规则难以充分正当化处理结论或者利益冲突复杂时,考察规则背后所要保护的公共利益,并通过利益衡量评判公共利益损害程度及个人利益的法律容纳空间.以上三种评价由程序到实体、由形式到实质加以展开,共同构成违法建筑认定的层次化判断框架.
Abstract:
The premise of governing illegal buildings is its determination according to law,and such determination is,in essence,a legal assessment of the illegality of a building.In practice,whether planning permission has been obtained is often used as the standard for determining a illegal building.However,the absence of planning permission can only reveal the procedural illegality of the construction behavior;it cannot give a definite answer to whether the building violates substantive rules.If the permission status alone is taken as the basis for determination,it is difficult to respond adequately to the social reality that illegal buildings often arise from complex causes and involve multiple interests.The assessment of the illegality of illegal buildings can be divided into three progressive levels.Procedural assessment is focused on planning permission and confirms whether the construction behavior violates the ex ante construction administration and control procedure.Substantive assessment takes substantive statutory rules on land use,territorial spatial protection,urban and rural planning,and technical standards as the basis to determine whether the building violates binding substantive rules.Substantial assessment,in situations where substantive rules are insufficient,the formal application of rules cannot fully justify the disposition,or conflicts of interests are complex,further examines the public interests protected underlying the rules and,through interest balancing,assesses the degree of harm to public interests and the legal scope for accommodating individual interests.These three forms of assessment unfold progressively from procedure to substantiveness and from form to substance,and together constitute a layered framework for determining illegal buildings.
刊 名 政治与法律 ISTICPKU
年,卷(期): 2026, (9)
分类号: DF3
机标分类号: D9 TU984 TP393
在线出版日期: 2026年10月19日
基金项目: 21BFX171:国家社会科学基金,