摘要
数据经济的本质是知识经济,它变革了我们的生产、生活方式,也改变了市场的知识分工,导致了知识垄断和社会不公.数据财产由此从一个单纯的私法归属问题,转变为须兼顾私法初次分配和公法再分配的社会分配问题.在私法的初次分配上,用户所有说和共享模式均有不足,数据财产应当分配给作为数据处理者的企业:由于用户对个人数据生成的贡献不构成劳动,数据在被收集之前也不具有稀缺性,归用户所有不符合规范评价;共享模式既存在用户所有说的局限,也无从确定用户的份额,不具有可操作性;企业的收集、处理行为构成劳动,由其取得数据财产更符合效率,企业的数据财产权也得到了司法的确认.数据财产的初次分配与再分配存在规范联系,二者可在相对所有权的概念下获得统一.数据财产的再分配应通过全民所有、对数据处理者课征与传统税种并行的数据专门税的方式进行.
The essence of the data economy is the knowledge economy.It not only transforms our way of production and lifestyle but also changes the division of knowledge in the market,leading to knowledge monopoly and social injustice.As a result,the issue of data property has shifted from a simple matter of private law ownership to a social distribution issue that necessitates the balance the initial distribution under private law and the redistribution under public law.In the initial distribution under private law,both the user-ownership theory and the sharing model have deficiencies.Data property should be allocated to enterprises as data processors.Since users' contributions to the generation of personal data do not constitute labor,and data is not scarce before being collected,it does not meet the normative evaluation for data to be owned by users.The sharing model not only has the limitations of the user-ownership theory but also cannot determine users' share,so it is not operational.The collecting and processing behaviors of enterprises constitute labor,so it is more efficient for enterprises to obtain data property,and their data property rights have also been confirmed by the judiciary.There exists a normative nexus between the initial distribution and redistribution of data property,and the two can be unified under the concept of relative ownership.The redistribution of data property shall be carried out by means of ownership by the whole people,i.e.imposing a special data tax in addition to the traditional taxes on data processors.