论约定在职竞业限制效力判定的规范构造
The Normative Framework for Determining the Validity of In-Employment Non-Compete Agreement
摘要
对约定在职竞业限制的效力判定,现行法未有明确规定.既有司法裁判与理论探讨多聚焦于在职竞业限制义务的法律属性,未对效力判定的规范构造有深入研究.通过比较在职与离职后竞业限制的差异,可知离职后竞业限制条款的效力判定以商业秘密的财产权面向为考察核心具有合理性,但同样的规范构造并不适用于在职竞业限制条款,《最高人民法院关于审理劳动争议案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第13条"知悉、接触商业秘密"要件应限缩解释为仅适用于离职后竞业限制条款.在职竞业限制因与劳动关系同步运行,对其效力的判定应更侧重对缔约双方信任关系状况的评估,即应基于劳动者身份进行类型化的规范构造.高级管理人员的在职竞业限制条款是对我国《公司法》规定的法定义务的具体化约定,自委任关系成立时生效;高级技术人员的在职竞业限制条款是对劳动合同附随义务的具体化约定,自劳动关系成立时生效;其他普通劳动者的在职竞业限制则为独立明示约定义务,宜将"未知悉、接触商业秘密"确定为劳动者法定解除权的取得条件而非条款的生效条件.
There is no explicit provision on the determination of the validity of in-employment non-compete agreement in current laws.Existing judicial practice and theoretical discussion are predominantly focused on the legal characterization of such obligations,leaving the normative framework of validity determination underexplored.Through a comparative analysis of in-employment and post-employment non-compete restriction,it is found that it is reasonable to take the proprietary dimension of trade secret as the core of examination for determining the validity of post-employment non-compete clauses;however,the same normative framework is not applicable to in-employment non-compete clauses,and the requirement of"knowing or having access to trade secret"under Article 13 of the Interpretation(Ⅱ)on Labor Disputes of the Supreme People's Court should be narrowly construed as applicable solely to post-employment non-compete clauses.Because in-employment non-compete restriction operates synchronously with the employment relationship,for its validity determination,greater weight should be placed on the assessment of the state of trust between the contracting parties,namely,the normative framework should be categorized on basis of the employee's status.For senior officers,in-employment non-compete clauses constitute a concrete agreement of statutory duties under the Company Law and take effect upon the establishment of the fiduciary relationship;for senior technical personnel,such clauses represent a concrete agreement of the ancillary obligations under the employment contract and take effect upon the formation of the employment relationship;for other ordinary employees,in-employment non-compete restriction constitutes an independent and express contractual duty,and it is advisable to designate"not knowing or having access to trade secrets"as a condition for the employee's acquisition of a statutory right of rescission rather than as a condition precedent to the effectiveness of the clause.
年,卷(期):
2026, (9)
分类号:
DF472
机标分类号:
D922.52
F249.26
F832.51
在线出版日期:
2026年10月19日
基金项目:
21BFX206:国家社会科学基金,